Vibram Lawsuit

Jun 05, 2014

About a month ago I posted about the claim from the media and running magazines that the minimalism trend was over or fading and my response to this. Over the rest of the year it should be interesting to see what happens with the current lawsuit that has been filed against Vibram and their five finger product. Just to be clear, the lawsuit is not about wearing these shoes causing injury, but the fact that Vibram has made claims that has not been backed by research, wearing their shoes will do the following:

Five Fingers

1. strengthen muscles in the feet and lower legs
2. improve range of motion in the ankles, feet, and toes
3. stimulate neural function important to balance and agility
4. eliminate heel lift to align the spine and improve posture
5. allow the foot and body to move naturally

This is very true there is minimal evidence proving this, but I would like to address these statements with some personal and clinical experience. Just to re-iterate I am not saying that these are claims from Vibram are true just a few things to think about from another perspective.

Five Fingers

1. strengthen muscles in the feet and lower legs. I consider a traditional running shoe (limited flexibility and preventing certain movements) like a brace, so an analogy would be wearing a semi-rigid wrist brace (no injury) and going to the gym and doing wrist curls, to strengthen your forearm. do you think it would benefit you more to work your wrist without the brace?
2. improve range of motion in the ankles, feet, and toes. hard to really prove, but wearing a traditional running shoe does seem to limit certain movements and change how we run.
3. stimulate neural function important to balance and agility. When I am working with a client in the clinic with a lower extremity injury, I always incorporate balance exercises into the exercise program. When I get a client to do these exercises I have them barefoot. This is something I have done prior to the barefoot running trend taking off a few years ago.
4. eliminate heel lift to align the spine and improve posture. This statement in theory makes sense, yes being barefoot puts you in a more natural posture compared to a shoe that has a heel to forefoot height difference, but does it help to improve your posture?
5. allow the foot and body to move naturally. I have come across many studies and videos, showing the difference between running shod and running barefoot. When you put on a pair of shoes generally we do alter the way we run, especially with an increased heel toe drop. Our body has been designed to reduce impact naturally when we run or walk. Do we want to alter that with a running shoe or promote it?

On the opposite side of the spectrum, the running shoe industry pushes that their shoes offer more protection and cushioning and better support, but their advertising is less blatant as Vibram’s claims. It is tough to find conclusive research that wearing a shoe that provides more cushioning, pronation or supination control, helps you run better, or prevents injuries. Some studies show that really it does not matter if we are fitted for the proper shoe or not. All the talk of cushioning and support when you run sounds more re-assuring than a thin piece of rubber under our foot.

I think there is a place for Vibram and running shoes and we need to work on finding a common ground. I do see that trend happening in footwear, but these things take time. I have a pair of very minimal shoes that I will continue to use a tool to maintain my form and strengthen my foot. I will also continue to purchase shoes that are minimal and offer some protection but do not alter the way I naturally run.



Please add your bio info through your member profile page, or through your dashboard.


Posted By


Tag Cloud

cervogenic headachesrunners kneestrength trainingeasterpatellar tendonitissports injurycupping therapy in st albertsleepITU World Grand Final Triathlon Edmontonlong covidneedlingrib paindeath racecarpal tunnelmarathonvirtual rehabintraoral massageHealth Information Act100 mileclinic closurecornmale pelvic healtharthritis of the spineAlberta Health Services funded Physiotherapyathlete injurydry needlingprolapseshoulder painremembrance dayBikesecondary submittingconcussionneedling techniquesexercise programconcussion recoverygolf injuriessafe exercises during pregnancypelvic girdle painbaseline testingtext necktrainingitupelvic health physiotherapyupper back painpelvic health physiotherapistcycling injury preventionavoiding injurylateral epicondylitissoccer injuriesachillesstretchingtrail runningrecoveryvolunteerSI joint painmechanical stress10 mileryegbikestrengthcustom fit compression stockingstrapsstroller runningBPPVst albert road racepregnant runnerGLA:D® EdmontonDiastasis Rectus Abdominis (DRA)injury preventionwhat to expectwhy active physio worksRunvictoria daygrand openingctv morning liveswimmerfast trax ultraSt. Albert Triathlonmassage therapymagrathWinter Injury Preventionshockwave therapyfirst appointmentSCAT 310kmrehabilitationlost souls ultratournamentiron legsbarefoot runningworking from homerotator cuffmarathon trainingfort saskatchewanhiking in the mountainsroad runningdraw prizesms bike tour 2019active physio workscanada dayspin classacupunctureturkey on the trailsworld physical therapy daybowen therapypelvic floorrunning gaitIT band syndromefundraiseredmonton physiotherapistarthritisconcussion testingthoracic spine mobilitymyofascial cupping therapyknee painst. albert road racemodalitiesfootballair relaxms bike tour leduc to camrosepost covid programhip impingmentobstacle coursecovid protocolsedmontonWPTDmassagemud runstaying fit while pregnantglobal edmontoncharityfestivaldraw prizeSwimpelvic organ prolapselifestyle expopartner massageglute strengthfoot paincortisonebreathworkfort saskatchewan chamber of commerceout run rareschoolrunning with babyms bike tourpole walkingultra runninglegacy park family festivalGLA:D™holiday hoursconcussion in sportMS Bike Tour 2020medical mission to Ecuador#teamrehabRaceback painheadachephysiotherapieprehab before rehabfasciaHawrelak Parkdirect billingcupping in st albertworld grand final edmontonheadachesMS Bikewinter runningpreventing sports injuriesoperation esperanzacommunity eventphysiotherapycovid 19 updateheel painbest of T8NSt. AlbertACLyou can ride twoactive physio works teamdizzinessachillies tendinopathyIntramuscular Stimulationplantar faciitisankle sprainwrist painice#fundraisingeaster mondayphysical therapyphysiotherapy for cancer patientstriathlonhip painkidsthoracic spinewarm hands, warm hearts runworld championshipsclinic screeningcovid 19 rehab and recyclingservus placetreatment for headachespost covid 19 programcanada day paradermttrade showcuppingcanadian trailscancer carebellerose bike a thoncold weather runningwarm handsflexibilityfort saskatchewan trade showracingelbow painhikingswimmingcore strengtheningGunn theory of IMScommunity involvementTeam Rehabultrareturn to runningheatyegfitnessreturn to sportconussion in sporthip replacementshockwaveknee injuryscapulataperultrarunnerlow back painwhatever it takesknee replacement1km kids fun runsouth edmontontrail runmotor vehicle accidentst albert triathlonst albertPHYSIOTHÉRAPIE EN FRANCAIS10milercovid 19small business nomineeGLA:D®telerehabrestrental car motor vehicle accidentTMJfrozen shoulderbackpack safetygolfer's elbowhockey injurymuscle tightnessUrinary Incontinencerunning injuriesstrengtheningOsteoarthritisrunning formprotectcovid19#msbikewhat is physiotherapyhockeyst. albert chamber of commerceplantar fasciitis#labourforloveGLA:D™ knee programDRAITU World Triathlon Grand Final EdmontonPRPyogavestibular rehabilitationregistered massage therapist5km obstacle courseultramarathonneck painroastrunningcouch to 5kWTS Edmontoncompressionrunning footwearrunning after babyurgent care physiotherapyrunning technique5kmPostureadaptive cyclingyardworkbowen techniqueshoulder massageyou can ride 2Diastasis Recticlavicle fracturectv edmontonGLA:D® St. Albertpricerotator cuff tearcomplete concussion management inc.ifcshin splintstennis elbowGLA:D™ back programvolleyballcovid 19 rehabroad raceIMSankle injuriesgait analysisactive physio works 5kmphysiotherapy albertaimPACT testingdave proctorfitness programinjection therapywarm hearttreating sports injuriesbasketball injuriessports concussionpelvic healthConnor McDavidpine to palmankle sprains in athletestraining planshockwave physiofoam rollerpainPhysiotherapy funding in Albertafamilyultrarunningpiraformis syndrome#activephysioworksshoulderextended health carecommunity runpre-natal fitnessironman canadastem cellslip and fallsACL injuriesconcussions in sporttrapezius strengtheningSAPECyegphysioSI jointgolfMS Bike Leduc to Camroseaquathonglute strengtheningcommunitydown and dirty obstacle coursetreatment planwork from homeparadedeath race training plangreat white north triathlonBest Physiotherapistpiraformisreaders choice awardsrunning during pregnancyconcussion mythsclinic update5kricephysio for golfvertigoregistered massage therapyguided massagerunning shoesinjurygood fridayjaw painpregnancy back painst albert 10 mileredmonton oilerskids of steel triathlonexplore albertafundraisingconcussion managementvirtual carecupping therapycovid 19 rehab and recoveryPFPS


Archive

What to Expect

We understand that you may have a few questions before visiting our clinics for your initial appointment.

Book an Appointment

Book in for an appointment with one of our qualified Active Physio Works Physiotherapists &
Registered Massage Therapists.

Treatments

We understand each person is different so we offer a variety of techniques that are best suited to your individual needs.