Needling Therapy

Jul 08, 2021

Dry needling? Acupuncture? Intramuscular stimulation (IMS)? Which one is right for me?

Needling therapy has become very popular among allied health professional over the last few decades, with physical therapists, chiropractors, osteopaths and many more using needles in everyday practice. It has become so popular; some people visit these professionals strictly for needle therapy. Since the emergence of this intervention there has been multiple new styles of dry needling therapy, and people often do not know the difference. In this blog I will explain the 3 most common forms of needling therapy.

Acupuncture

Acupuncture originates back to 100 BC and has become very popular in western culture over the last 50 years. Acupuncture is based on an eastern philosophy and the concept of landmarks on the human body, known as “meridians or conduits” (figure 1), or energy-carrying channels, to alter a persons Qi, known as vital energy or lift force, which result in improvements in a range of health parameters (1). This is done by inserting very fine needles into the appropriate meridians of a person with their complaint to correct imbalance and restore health.

meridians-acu.png

                                                                               (figure 1)


Acupuncture has been researched and proven to be both safe and effective in reducing pain in people with chronic low back pain, knee osteoarthritis and headaches (2) as well as other conditions, like migraines (3). The reasons as to why acupuncture is effective not well understood, but it has shown to change descending brain signals and alter the levels inflammatory mediators in the location of pain (4).

 

Dry needling

Dry needling, as opposed to acupuncture, uses a western philosophy and the science of anatomy and neurology as its basis of treatment. It is defined as “A skilled intervention … that uses a thin filiform needle to penetrate the skin and stimulate underlying myofascial trigger points, muscular and connective tissues for the management of neuromusculoskeletal pain and movement impairments”. (5)

The trigger points that are targeted in dry needling uses Janet Travells research, an American physician, who mapped pain referral patterns of “trigger points” of several skeletal muscles (figure 2) (6). Trigger points are “A hyperirritable spot in skeletal muscle associated with a hypersensitive nodule in a taut band” (5).

trigger-points.png
                                                                          (figure 2)

These triggers points can cause common complaints of musculoskeletal pain, and when palpated, cause characteristic referred pain, as mapped out by Travell. The goal of dry needling is to target these trigger points at the center of the muscle belly, deep to the surface of the muscle, to reduce the pain they are causing. The only similarity between acupuncture and dry needling are the needles used for treatment.

Since dry needling is a new treatment method than acupuncture, the research is not as strong or well documented. Regardless, is has also shown to reduce pain in several musculoskeletal conditions but is similar in reducing pain to other non-needle therapies (7).

 

Gunn Intra-muscular stimulation

Intra-muscular stimulation (IMS) was created by Dr. Chan Gunn in British Columbia in the 1970’s while working with difficult musculoskeletal cases. Dr. Gunn’s philosophy relies on both Travells work of trigger points, and the belief that most pain is neuropathic in nature, meaning it primarily originates from the nerves. His work uses the western science and concepts from the radiculopathic model of pain, which suggests pain in the extremities is derived from compressed nerves in the spine (figure 3).

ims.png

                                                                        (figure 3)


The use of needles can release trigger points in muscles around the spine and reduce the pressure on these nerves, consequently reducing pain in the extremities (8).

The type of needles and technique used in IMS is very similar to dry needling, the primary difference is the reasoning and goal behind the use of the needles.

 

All of these different needle therapies can assist in managing pain and symptoms for several neuromusculoskeletal injuries. Which one is right for you depends on the person and several factors regarding their injury.

Active Physio Works has physiotherapists that are trained in all of these forms of needling, and each of them can guide you in the right direction for your best recovery! Call 780-458-8505 to book an appointment today!

 

References:

  1. White, A., & Ernst, E. (2004). A brief history of acupuncture. Rheumatology43(5), 662-663.
  2. Xiang, A., Cheng, K., Shen, X., Xu, P., & Liu, S. (2017). The immediate analgesic effect of acupuncture for pain: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine2017.
  3. Li, Y. X., Xiao, X. L., Zhong, D. L., Luo, L. J., Yang, H., Zhou, J., ... & Jin, R. J. (2020). Effectiveness and safety of acupuncture for migraine: an overview of systematic reviews. Pain Research and Management2020.
  4. Lai, H. C., Lin, Y. W., & Hsieh, C. L. (2019). Acupuncture-analgesia-mediated alleviation of central sensitization. Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine2019.
  5. Placzek, J. D., & Boyce, D. A. (2016). Orthopaedic physical therapy secrets-E-Book. Elsevier Health Sciences.
  6. Travell, J. G., & Simons, D. G. (1983). Myofascial pain and dysfunction: the trigger point manual (Vol. 2). Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
  7. Gattie, E., Cleland, J. A., & Snodgrass, S. (2017). The effectiveness of trigger point dry needling for musculoskeletal conditions by physical therapists: a systematic review and meta-analysis. journal of orthopaedic & sports physical therapy47(3), 133-149.
  8. https://www.gunnims.com/what-is-gunn-ims-dry-needling.html

 

 



Please add your bio info through your member profile page, or through your dashboard.


Posted By


Tag Cloud

cold weather runninginjection therapyultrarunnerknee replacementms bike tour 2019text neckfort saskatchewan chamber of commercecanada day paradetrail runthoracic spinerotator cuff tearvolleyballmagrath10km10milertechniquehalf ironmanhikingfasciaWTS Edmonton10 milephysiotherapy albertatraining on vacationpelvic girdle painheadachepole walkingedmonton oilerstrapswhat to expectmassage therapyactive physio works teamctv edmontonConnor McDavidmarathon runningGLA:D® St. Albertfrozen shoulderpelvic healthankle sprainshockwaveWestern Statesctv morning liverental car motor vehicle accidentolympian distance challengepost covid programclinic closurenutritionobstacle coursePHYSIOTHÉRAPIE EN FRANCAISGLA:D™ back programprotectbaseline testingPFPSSI jointcovid 19turkey on the trailsfoam rollericeankle sprains in athletesreturn to sportathlete injuryheel painstrengthsleepcovid-19ultraprehab before rehabmedical mission to Ecuadordeath race training plannational triathlon championshipsvertigoshockwave therapyneedlingrunning after babynational championshipsrunninghiking in the mountainsgolf injuriescat-scanrunning with babyBikeUrinary Incontinenceswimmingironman canadafirst appointmentcanada dayparadebarefoot runningpiraformisP-90Xjaw painrunning footwearpainifcMRIbowen techniquefundraiserplantar fasciitisbowen therapytrail runningwhy active physio worksyou can ride 2needling techniqueselbow painITU World Triathlon Grand Final Cozumelst. albert road racemarathonswimmercity chase national championshipcommunity involvementms bike tour leduc to camroserecoverytreatment for headachesrunning gaititubasketball injuriesyoga5kmmarathon trainingDiastasis Rectus Abdominis (DRA)SAPECpost covid 19 programseptember 30gait analysisdirect billingphysiotherapiebackpack safetybanff triathlonfast trax ultracovid19telerehabcovid 19 rehab and reHealth Information Actgolfconussion in sportconcussion managementkids fun runmotor vehicle accidenteasterDRAlost souls ultraslip and fallssafe exercises during pregnancyfootballSI joint pain5km obstacle courseregistered massage therapycarpal tunnellateral epicondylitisvirtual careeaster mondayrehabilitationbikes on broadwaySt. AlbertSt. Albert Triathloncommunityfoot painorthoticsRunACL injuriesextended health carecovid 19 rehabservus placecervogenic headachesadaptive cyclingplantar faciitissmall business nomineekids of steel triathlongreat white north triathlonreaders choice awardsimPACT testingp90xcupping in st albertfitness programorthopedic surgeonship replacementfirst triultrasoundhalf marathonst albert triathloncupping therapyvelocity stage racearthritisgrand openingWinter Injury Preventionst albertconcussionconcussions in sportpreventing sports injuriesHawrelak Parkyardworkcouch to 5kcycling racesports injuryprolapsedizzinessworking from homewarm heartsoccer injuriestrapezius strengtheningtournamentcompressionjames deanphysical therapyhockeyGLA:D® Edmontonblood flow restriction trainingcovid 19 rehab and recoverymodalitiesvirtual rehabrunners kneefort saskatchewanpartner massagecity chaseyou can ride twoedmonton physiotherapisttaperholiday hoursexercisePosturecommunity eventracingcore strengtheningshoulder painmud rundraw prizesst albert road racetriathlondr chanlong coviddown and dirty obstacle coursephysio for golfoperation esperanzaroad rage hockey tournamentlumbar spine imagingheatrunning techniquesports concussionCBC interviewcity chase national championshipsBFR trainingricevictoria daypelvic organ prolapsehockey injurywhatever it takestreating sports injuriespelvic health physiotherapistdraw prizeGunn theory of IMSintraoral massagespin classmale pelvic healtharthritis of the spinecommunity runkidsTeam Rehab#teamrehabadventure racingrunning shoesyegphysioactive physio works 5kmpre-natal fitnessmechanical stressexercise challengeiron legsgolfer's elbowlegacy park family festivalpatellar tendonitisknee injurymuscle tightnessyegfitrmtair relaxstaying fit while pregnantworld grand final edmontoncity chase canadafestivaldave proctorfitness journeytraining planITU World Triathlon Grand Final Edmontonroastheadachessynchronized skatingstroller runninglifestyle expocortisonefundraisingconcussion in sportfree fort bbqGLA:D®world championshipsinjury preventiontour de palm springsknee painHIITPRPmodified return to activitydry needlingstrength trainingpiraformis syndromevestibular rehabilitationRacediagnostic imagingstretchingexplore albertaskating5kglute strengthcustom fit compression stockingsrotator cuffwarm handsfernie ultrast. albert chamber of commercereturn to runningTMJtrade showworld physical therapy dayachillestreatment plantrainingIMSankle injuriesurgent care physiotherapyGLA:D™ knee program#eddiedontbendback painSwimMS Bike Leduc to Camrosedr shepswhat is physiotherapysecondary submittingms bike tourworkout planx-raydeath raceglobal edmontoncomplete concussion management inc.taperingMS Bikefamilyyegbikecupping therapy in st albertmassagefort saskatchewan trade showaquathonultrarunningshin splintswork from homeneck painbellerose bike a thonyegfitnessSCAT 3physiotherapy for cancer patientsniagara fallsWPTDpelvic health physiotherapy10 miler#activephysioworkswounded warriorspelvic floorworld triathlon championshipsrunning formexercise programshoulder imagingregistered massage therapistDiastasis Rectist albert 10 milercornsouth edmontonscapularest100 mileultramarathonfun in the forthip impingmentpine to palmcustom fit orthoticsstem cellflexibilitycharityIT band syndromeITU World Grand Final Triathlon Edmontonhip pain1km kids fun runtennis elbowavoiding injurygood fridaycanadian trailsOsteoarthritishigh intensity interval trainingguided massagefitnessmyofascial cupping therapyclavicle fracturebest of T8NACLcyclingglute strengtheningpriceIntramuscular Stimulationshoulderachillies tendinopathypregnancy back paincuppingGLA:D™acupunctureroad runningconcussion testingactive physio workscity chase world championshipnew york marathoncross trainingvolunteerremembrance dayedmontonultra runningrunning injuriesBest Physiotherapistcancer careironmanlow back painbellerose bike-a-thonshoulder massagewrist painpregnant runnerMS Bike Tour 2020road raceinjurywinter runningpush up programexercise plancycling injury preventionstrengtheningschoolrunning during pregnancythoracic spine mobility10 miler training plansinister 7physiotherapyout run rarekeep fit, have funBPPV


Archive

What to Expect

We understand that you may have a few questions before visiting our clinics for your initial appointment.

Book an Appointment

Book in for an appointment with one of our qualified Active Physio Works Physiotherapists &
Registered Massage Therapists.

Treatments

We understand each person is different so we offer a variety of techniques that are best suited to your individual needs.